lewleadbeater.com

notes from the edge

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

THE

Column Archive

 

 

 

VIRGINIA GAZETTE

 

 

 

 

WILLIAMSBURG, VIRGINIA

We could have done more

 

 

 

September 10, 2005

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

On this eve of September 11, we would do well to keep in mind the poignant words of Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld relative to our bungled effort in Iraq: “Stuff happens.” 

 

Yes, stuff does happen, and lots of stuff happened on August 29, when Katrina got it into her head to wipe out a good chunk of the Gulf Coast and New Orleans along with it. 

 

Five days after the hurricane, the New York Times printed on its front page a large picture taken by a photographer for Agence France Presse.  On the right side of the photo stands a black woman on an overpass, pouring precious water into a container for a bedraggled dog to drink. Below her, on the left, runs a grime-laden river in which, among the detritus, is floating the dead body of another woman, face down in the mucky water. 

 

Stuff happens.

 

As we all know by now, the stuff that happened after the hurricane was far more horrifying than the hurricane itself. In fact, so heart-wrenching has it been that many of us have come face to face with a shame so all-encompassing that its presence is almost overwhelming. 

 

 I suppose such manifestations of anger and embarrassment derive from the utter helplessness we all feel as individuals to do something meaningful in a disaster of this magnitude. We, who are citizens of the most resourceful and richest nation on earth, quite naturally feel that our government’s primary task is to secure our welfare, even in the midst of overwhelming odds.

 

But stuff happens.

 

Stuff like Katrina is totally beyond our control. Stuff that involves preparing for a Katrina or picking up the pieces after Katrina is not. In both these instances we have failed miserably. And that, I suppose, is the source of my shame.

 

I am ashamed of a government that, instead of heeding the warnings of its own Army Corps of Engineers, slashed over $60 million from the Corps’ request to fortify levees and enhance flood control in New Orleans. Thus the civility of a vibrant American city was transformed into the barbarism of Mogadishu because the money that might have saved it was diverted to Homeland Security and the maniacal war in Iraq. 

 

I am ashamed of an administration that would order nearly 8,000 Louisiana and Mississippi National Guard troops and their equipment – including high water vehicles – to be sent to Iraq and thus leave their people at home vulnerable to overpowering natural disasters. Five days after the hurricane, there were still no troops, no equipment, no succor of any kind on the ground in the areas devastated by Katrina.

 

I am ashamed of a president who, on the day after the hurricane, felt it imperative to fly off to San Diego for a Republican joy fest. And a vice president who, according to New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd, was checking out for purchase a $2.9 million mansion on the Chesapeake Bay while bodies were floating down the streets of New Orleans.  

 

I am ashamed of a president who had the gall to tell the American people that no one could have predicted what transpired in the Gulf. Katrina was moving out of Florida on Thursday and forecasters were warning of her intensity and her track even then. They predicted it. 

 

According to a recent series in the New Orleans Times-Picayune, the Army Corps of Engineers has for years trumpeted the fact that New Orleans could not sustain more than a category 3 hurricane. The levees simply wouldn’t hold. They predicted it. 

 

I am ashamed of a president who would install as director of FEMA a political hack and crony whose only experience prior to his investiture was raising Arabian horses and running horse races. 

 

But most of all I’m ashamed of a country that would grant ultimate power to people who are so far removed from poverty that they are totally ignorant of the disgrace, degradation and yes, death, that it can spawn in times of utter destruction.

 

How many faces of the poor – young, old, decrepit and penniless – do we have to see filing out of the sewer that was the Superdome before we realize that this country is wallowing in classism, racism and a total lack of concern for those less fortunate? 

 

Americans are now showering the Red Cross and other relief organizations with wads of money, but where were we before? Why have these poor souls without resources to evacuate a  city in its death throes been allowed to fall through the gigantic cracks that have been there all along?

 

Rather than recognizing such dire discrepancies in our society, the Republicans in congress are even now preparing to drastically cut Medicaid and slews of anti-poverty programs for the sake of continuing tax cuts to the rich and maintaining our dubious presence in Iraq.  For shame.  

 

Bush and his Republican cronies have obviously graduated from the Marie Antoinette school of managing poverty and pauperism. Let them eat cake.

 

Stuff happens.

 

Yes, right now I’m ashamed to be an American. I’m ashamed of my government, I’m ashamed of my president, and I’m ashamed of myself for not doing more to aid those of my fellow Americans who are now and have been for years in such desperate straits.

 

 The idea that stuff happens no longer cuts it.  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

lewleadbeater.com  Copyright 2002  All Rights Reserved    email: LWL@lewleadbeater.com