lewleadbeater.com

notes from the edge

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

THE

Column Archive

 

 

 

VIRGINIA GAZETTE

 

 

 

 

WILLIAMSBURG, VIRGINIA

Shape up, Neighbor

 

 

 

May 22, 2002

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Want to grill some steaks on the barbie tonight? Sorry, you can’t do it. How about  setting out some poignant potted pansies along your front walk? Can’t do that either. Maybe you’d like to put up a basketball hoop for the kids on the garage door.  Out of the question.

 

Hanging the clothes out to dry on a sunny day? You must be kidding. Got home late and you want to do a wash before you go to bed?  Not if it’s after 10 PM. Tired of painting rotting wood? Want to cover it with vinyl or aluminum siding?  You must be out of your mind. You’ve got to understand that your neighborhood has standards, and they will be enforced! 

 

And so they are. Homeowners’ associations and the architectural control boards they spawn have come to be the bane of many residents in gated and some non-gated  communities throughout Greater Williamsburg. In most of these places, homeowners and prospective homeowners are being channeled into a type of conformity that makes Levittown look like the epitome of diversity. 

 

Some of these control boards are offshoots of the Williamsburg Architectural Review Board, which is appointed by, and hence accountable to, City Council. As a result, it generally gets high marks from architects in the area. In an attempt to keep the residential areas near Colonial Williamsburg from descending into the unkempt and garish, the Board has issued broad guidelines that most citizens in the affected areas can live with – and indeed appreciate.

 

Not so the neighborhood boards. These groups, made up for the most part of resident volunteers, have, in the name of maintaining aesthetic standards, become taste police. Fearing lest the Beverly Hillbillies are going to invade their neighborhoods and, like Mammy Yokum, poach possum on the front porch, they opt for a conformity and control that completely obviates individuality. 

 

Architects cringe at their guidelines, which seem to change with the whims of the committee du jour. They find themselves nonplussed by regulations that violate the freedom that makes architecture the art it is. As one local architect put it, these committees are all too often “invasive, tyrannical and mess with peoples’ personal habits.”

 

What they do, in fact, is assume the worst not only of their present residents, but of those who would like to join their communities. The operative philosophy seems to be that if they don’t tell residents what they can do with their property, the community will go to pot and property values will take a deep dive and never come up.  Hence pages and pages of convoluted codes are developed, each one a potential stumbling block for the architect and his or her client.

 

Driveways are put in according to code, only to be dismissed later as unacceptable. Flowers are planted in front yards, only to be torn out because they violate regulations.  Some window shapes are acceptable and some aren’t. And don’t even mention roof pitches or house paints. Nor should you consider doing anything in front of your house. Do it in the backyard or don’t do it at all.

 

But even there you’re not safe.

 

In one community, a resident constructed in his backyard a small brick shed to cover his air conditioner and house his lawn tools. No sooner was it built than he was told by the  control board that it had to come down. It was against regulations. So now the air conditioner is in full view, and the tools are piled up along the back of the house. Obviously this arrangement is more pleasing to the eye than that illegal brick shed. 

 

In yet another neighborhood, a resident in the midst of a barbecue party in his back yard was set upon by the control Gestapo, who told him that barbecues were verboten  and that he’d have to move his party elsewhere.

 

But perhaps most unsettling is the fact that these control boards have become so entrenched that they  have neighbors spying on neighbors and reporting minor violations to their boards. One poor soul was hauled up before his board because a neighbor patrolling the area caught him running his washing machine after 10PM.

 

Still another victim, who felt compelled to write a letter to the editor ( May 18 Gazette), was told that she was disgracing the neighborhood with her unkempt lawn and her multiplicity of cars.  She, of course, insists that her lawn is well kept and that the cars are neatly stored. 

 

In short, if you’re going to live in one of these places, be ready to forfeit your individuality and whatever personal tastes and habits violate their conformity codes. According to one Williamsburg architect, what these boards prefer more than anything is that you show no signs of life whatsoever. 

 

Reach Lew Leadbeater on website www.lewleadbeater.com   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

lewleadbeater.com  Copyright 2002  All Rights Reserved    email: LWL@lewleadbeater.com